Lack of Facilities Discourages Former Judges from Joining Tribunals, Supreme Court Observes

In a significant observation, the Supreme Court has highlighted that many retired judges are reluctant to accept appointments to tribunals due to inadequate facilities, poor infrastructure, and lack of respect accorded to them after taking up such roles.

 

A bench comprising Justice B.V. Nagarathna and Justice R. Mahadevan expressed concern that even after being appointed, several former judges decline to join tribunals because they are not provided with basic amenities such as official residences, proper office space, and adequate staff.

 

The Solicitor General informed the court that four appointees have refused to take up tribunal positions for these reasons. He acknowledged that the absence of essential facilities and bureaucratic hurdles are major deterrents preventing former judges from accepting these roles.

 

Justice Nagarathna remarked that post-retirement dignity and respect are crucial factors for judges when considering tribunal appointments. They should not feel neglected or treated as ordinary employees after serving the nation in high judicial offices.

 

The court urged the government and concerned authorities to improve infrastructure and working conditions of tribunals, ensuring that former judges receive due respect and support. This, the bench noted, is vital for strengthening the tribunal system and ensuring its effective functioning.

 

Additionally, the court recommended forming a five-member selection committee to oversee future tribunal appointments and address existing challenges. The matter will be heard again on September 16 for further directions.