Landmark Labour Law Judgements
Supported by Labour Law Reporter
1. KARNATAKA – Karnataka High Court
1. Bonus beyond 8.33% cannot be claimed as a matter of right.
Bonus in addition to 8.33% cannot be claimed as a right merely because it was paid in previous years.
Pharmacutical Chemical & Allied Employees Union v. The Management of M/s. J.L. Morrison (India) Limited
Citation: 2018 LLR 1194 (Karn. HC)
2. PF applicability to establishments functioning together.
Two establishments functioning together and employing a combined total of 20 employees will be covered under the Provident Fund legislation.
Om Investment Corporation, Bangalore v. Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, EPFO, Bangalore
Citation: 2009 LLR 990 (Karn. HC)
3. Correction of date of birth at the end of service.
Correction of an employee's date of birth is not permissible at the fag end of service.
Management of M/s. Woodlands Hotel (P) Ltd. v. G.N. Gundappa
Citation: 2014 LLR 87 (Karn. HC)
4. Conduct of trade union office-bearers.
Trade union office-bearers must demonstrate integrity and hard work so that they serve as role models for other employees.
Krishnappa M. v. Bharat Electronics Ltd., represented by its General Manager (ES) & Another
Citation: 2018 LLR 957 (Karn. HC)
5. Dismissal for absence supported by medical certificate.
Dismissal for absence is not justified when an employee has applied for leave supported by a medical certificate.
North-East Karnataka Road Transport Corporation v. Sayed Abdul Raheem
Citation: 2019 LLR 1105 (Karn. HC)
6. Validity of charge-sheet for involvement in other business.
A charge-sheet issued to an employee for involvement in another business will not be considered vague when the names and addresses of the business firms are specifically mentioned.
Davendra Kumar v. N.G.E.F. Ltd.
Citation: 2000 LLR 705 (Karn. HC)
2. DELHI – Delhi High Court
1. Earned leave during suspension.
An employee under suspension will not be entitled to earned leave.
Central Bank of India v. Shyam Lal Jain
Citation: 2010 LLR (SN) 893 (Del. HC)
2. Employer-provided accommodation.
An employee provided with accommodation by the employer will be treated as a licensee and not a tenant.
Emmanuel Prem Masih v. Delhi Diocesan Trust Association
Citation: 2000 LLR 1028 (Del. HC)
3. Domestic enquiry in cases involving loss of confidence.
The employer is not required to hold an enquiry in a case of misconduct resulting in loss of confidence, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
Delhi State Civil Supply Corporation Ltd. v. Sh. Badan Singh
Citation: 2019 LLR 1189 (Del. HC)
4. Employment offer after apprenticeship.
An apprentice cannot refuse an offer of employment after successful completion of the training period, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
Sanjay Kumar v. Union of India
Citation: (1994) 54 DLT 403; 1994 LLR 557; (1994) II CLR 916; 1994-II LLN 339 (Del. HC)
3. MAHARASHTRA – Bombay High Court
1. Appointment of an external enquiry officer.
An outsider may conduct a domestic enquiry when the applicable Standing Orders do not prohibit such an appointment.
Sandvik Asia Ltd. v. Maruti Mahipati Jagadale
Citation: (2002) 94 FLR 1086; (2002) 2 CLR 1018; 2002 LLR 1138 (Bom. HC)
2. Assault occurring away from the workplace.
Assault of an employee by other employees far away from the workplace will not constitute misconduct, according to the supplied case summary.
P.V. Pujari v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay
Citation: (1994) 68 FLR 1124; 1995 LLR 125; 1995 LIC 157 (Bom. HC)
3. Provident Fund coverage from the date of joining.
Coverage of an employee under the Provident Fund legislation from the date of joining will not be illegal.
Kay Iron Works (Pvt.) Ltd. v. Union of India
Citation: 2007 LLR 175 (Bom. HC)
4. Burden of proof regarding unfair domestic enquiry.
The burden of proving that a domestic enquiry was unfair lies upon the worker and not the management, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
Narang Latex and Dispersions (Pvt.) Ltd. v. S.V. Suvarna
Citation: 1994 LLR 543; 1995 I LLJ 113 (Bom. HC)
4. PUNJAB & HARYANA – Punjab and Haryana High Court
1. Delay in filing a writ petition.
A writ petition may be held untenable where there is an unexplained and inordinate delay in filing it.
Iqbal Singh v. Presiding Officer
Citation: 2014 LLR 265 (P&H HC)
2. Calculation of 240 days of continuous service.
The calculation of 240 days of service shall be based on the preceding 12 calendar months.
Bharti v. The Presiding Officer
Citation: 2016 LLR 1050 (P&H HC)
3. Contract labour and employment relationship.
Merely working for a long period through a contractor does not automatically establish that a worker is an employee of the principal employer.
Sona Devi v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal and Another
Citation: 2023 LLR 395 (P&H HC)
4. Sickness period and continuous service.
The period of sickness of an employee will be counted as continuous service.
Durga Prasad, Faridabad v. Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court I, Faridabad
Citation: (2001) II LLJ 549; 2001 LLR 1036 (P&H HC)
5. UTTAR PRADESH – Allahabad High Court
1. Back wages and proof of unemployment.
Back wages cannot be awarded if the concerned workman fails to assert before the Industrial Tribunal that he remained unemployed during the pendency of the industrial dispute.
Hridyanand v. G.P. Stores, Allahabad
Citation: 1996 LLR 433 (All. HC)
2. Sham contract labour arrangement.
A contract labour system may be treated as sham when wages are paid directly by the principal employer, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
Indian Farmers Fertiliser Co-operative Ltd. v. Presiding Officer, Labour Court
Citation: 2015 LLR 505 (All. HC)
3. Seniority of women members of the Internal Complaints Committee.
A woman member of the Internal Complaints Committee (ICC) is not necessarily required to be senior in rank to the complainant.
Smt. Shobha Goswami v. State of Uttar Pradesh
Citation: 2015 LLR 1038 (All. HC)
6. GUJARAT – Gujarat High Court
1. Overtime claim when employer fails to rebut evidence.
A claim for overtime wages may be accepted when the employer fails to rebut the claim.
Botad Nagar Palika v. General Secretary, Rashtriya Mazdoor Sangh, Rajkot
Citation: 2007 LLR 35 (Guj. HC)
2. Refusal to work and abandonment of service.
Refusal by a worker to work at the assigned site along with the team may amount to abandonment of service.
Vantage Advertising Pvt. Ltd. v. JavedaliKutubali Hashmi
Citation: 2011 LLR 197 (Guj. HC)
3. Removal of employee's name for unauthorised absence.
Striking the name of a worker from the employment rolls merely because of unauthorised absence is improper.
Mayank Desai v. Sayaji Iron & Engineering Co. Ltd.
Citation: 2011 LLR 536 (Guj. HC)
7. HIMACHAL PRADESH – Himachal Pradesh High Court
1. Continuation of Industrial Tribunal proceedings.
Proceedings before the Industrial Tribunal continue until the award becomes enforceable.
Harbans Singh v. Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court
Citation: 2016 LLR 802 (HP HC)
2. Prolonged absence and voluntary retirement.
When a workman remains absent for more than two years, such absence may amount to voluntary retirement, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
State of Himachal Pradesh v. Presiding Judge
Citation: 2006 LLR 1020 (HP HC)
8. TAMIL NADU – Madras High Court
1. Transfer of worker and change in service conditions.
In the absence of any specific provision governing the transfer of a worker, notice of change in service conditions becomes imperative.
Chennai Port and Dock Workers Congress (INTUC) v. Union of India
Citation: (2002) 94 FLR 1072; 2002 LLR 1090 (Mad. HC)
2. Power of High Court to modify punishment.
A High Court exercising writ jurisdiction may modify the punishment imposed in a disciplinary matter.
Sayed Khadar Mohiuddin v. Chairman, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission
Citation: (1997) II LLJ 111; 1999 LLR 88 (Mad. HC)
9. JHARKHAND – Jharkhand High Court
1. Acceptance of resignation by employer.
A resignation becomes complete only after it has been accepted by the employer, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
Om Dutta Sharma v. State of Jharkhand
Citation: 2017 LLR 282 (Jhar. HC)
10. MADHYA PRADESH – Madhya Pradesh High Court
1. EPF damages and compliance with due procedure.
Levying damages by the Employees' Provident Fund Authority without following the prescribed procedure is not legally sustainable.
Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner v. M/s. Kanya Kubj Lime Works
Citation: 2012 LLR 1096 (MP HC)
11. RAJASTHAN – Rajasthan High Court
1. Refusal to perform emergency duty on weekly off.
Refusal by a driver to perform emergency duty on a weekly off may justify dismissal from service, as stated in the supplied judgment summary.
Mohan Singh v. Jaipur Metals & Electrical Ltd., Jaipur
Citation: (1996) II LLJ 551; 1996 LLR 448 (Raj. HC)
12. WEST BENGAL – Calcutta High Court
1. Factory inspection without prior notice.
A Factory Inspector is not required to serve advance notice before inspecting factory premises.
Rupinder Singh Sodhi v. State of West Bengal and Another
Citation: 2020 LLR 391 (Cal. HC)
13. SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
1. Past service record in disciplinary punishment.
The past service record of a worker may be relevant while determining the punishment to be imposed by the employer in disciplinary proceedings.
Management of TNSTC (Coimbatore) Ltd. v. M. Chandrasekaran
Citation: 2016 LLR 1009 (SC)
14. COURT NOT SPECIFIED IN THE SOURCE DOCUMENT
1. Exemption from Employees' Pension Scheme.
Exemption from the pension scheme can be granted only to establishments and not to individual employees or groups of employees.
H.M.T. Ex-servicemen's Association v. Union of India
Citation: 2001 LLR 697
The source document does not identify the court delivering this judgment.
